Sunday, 31 July 2016

Which Movies Could Be Better Told From The Antagonist's Perspective?


 Actually, most already are.
As I came to answer this, I thought about some movies where the "good guys" are obviously bad and realised that to tell the story from the real "good guys" angle would make the plot fall apart.
Notable Examples:
  • The Matrix
  • Blade Runner
  • Natural Born Killers
  • Pulp Fiction
Then you have the case where the good guys and the bad guys are both as bad as each other
Notable Examples:
  • Star Wars
  • Inside Man
  • Watchmen
  • Law Abiding Citizen
  • Clockwork Orange
Now I don't have a problem with morally ambiguous material. In fact, I'm all for it because it's more intereting - when it is intentionally written that way. I have a problem with it when it's the result of bad writing ie when a writer goes out to make a hero but a plot hole in the badly written story makes the hero unintentionally flawed in a way that demolishes the whole story.
A classic example is almost every superhero movie where the superhero appears to have absolutely no interest in the collateral damage they are a party to just so long as the villain is caught. I have never once seen a hero take the fight somewhere where no one would be hurt or coordinate with the emergency services to get people to safety or even help in the clean up afterwards - and they're the heroes? I don't think so.
The problem is context.
Few movie writers think of their stories as part of a whole. Each action, each word, has consequences. And if you don't think about them, they will ripple out, hit an object and bounce back, destroying the original pattern that created them.

No comments:

Post a Comment